Trivial Einstein<p>Once again, Social Security is not a bank. It's not that I don't think people deserve to get what they worked for, but I think people deserve to get social security regardless of whether they've worked a day in their lives. Social Security being dismantled will not result in seniors "not getting their hard-earned money," because their money has already been paid to people who were getting social security when the current crop of seniors was working.</p><p>When we view Social Security as a bank, we play into the hands of people who only want "deserving" people to get Social Security. That's not at all how it works, and that's not how it should work. Social Security is a scheme whereby the government gives financial security to people who don't work. Everything else is just an implementation detail.</p><p>Yes, I know that one's work history is taken into account. Yes, I know that currently the money is raised via a special tax. But those things could change fairly easily, and suddenly you've got a UBI.</p><p>By viewing Social Security as a fund into which you pay, to later withdraw your funds, you allow the framing that Social Security can ever go bankrupt. It can't. The government can (and it seems likely will) stop paying it out, but that's a choice, not a bitter necessity. You also allow privatization: if Social Security is an investment, why not invest it privately in the stock market or something? But it isn't. It's a budget line item. I am aware that there is a Social Security (which I keep having to type out because the acronym is unfortunate) slush fund, but that's an implementation detail.</p><p>You won't get what you paid into Social Security back. It's gone. It got paid to your grandparents, most likely. But imagine if the safety of society, a kind of net of some kind, was given a bunch of money through the government taxing billionaires. It would certainly improve the social security of everyone. So why not give some of that money to everyone every month? And what if we just did that?</p><p>Yeah, it'll never happen, right?</p><p><a href="https://beige.party/tags/subtoot" class="mention hashtag" rel="nofollow noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">#<span>subtoot</span></a></p>